Carneades
quoted 17 times by 7 works · as a person
also in the atlas: Carneades the figure
Most often carried — quoted as a source. The locus given for each is the passage in the quoting book; the harvest records no place inside what is quoted, and nothing here pretends to.
2 quoted · 6 reported · 9 carried
6 neutral 8 refuted 3 extendedin the voice of Carneades 3 , Antiochus 1 , Aulus Albinus 1 , Cicero 1 , the speaker 1
quoted by
7 works-
in the voice of Carneades
-
Tusculan Disputations Cicero, Marcus Tullius 3 neutral 4 refuted 7 citations · 6 passages
Represents the reported speech act of Carneades's disputation transmitted through Clitomachus's notebook.
in it is written a disputation of Carneades, which he says he set down in a notebook.
book 3 ¶ -
in the voice of Cicero
-
On Moral Ends Cicero, Marcus Tullius 1 neutral 1 refuted 1 extended 3 citations
Corresponds to the citation of Carneades's constructed doctrine
The same things may be said against that Carneadean highest good, which he brought forward not so much to prove it as to set it against the Stoics, with whom he waged war.
book 2 ¶ -
in the voice of Aulus Albinus
-
Lucullus Cicero, Marcus Tullius 1 neutral 1 refuted 2 citations
This corresponds to the citation of Carneades's doctrine, required to have a matching citation_quote event.
Wherefore whether you propose a probable appearance, or a probable one and one not impeded, as Carneades wished, or some other thing which you may follow, you will have to return to that impression about which we are speaking.
book 1 ¶ -
in the voice of the speaker
-
On the Nature of the Gods Cicero, Marcus Tullius 2 refuted 2 citations
The passage reports that Carneades argued against a specific philosophical position.
Against them Carneades argued at such length as to rouse men of any energy to a desire for discovering the truth.
book 1 ¶ -
Academica Cicero, Marcus Tullius 1 extended 1 citation
Corresponds to the citation of Carneades as extending the Academic tradition.
This New Academy, carried down as far as Carneades, who was fourth from Arcesilas, remained in the same method of Arcesilas.
book 1 ¶ -
On Fate Cicero, Marcus Tullius 1 extended 1 citation
The text explicitly presents Carneades's argument as a structured conclusion attributed to him by name.
Carneades did not approve of this whole kind of reasoning, and thought that this argument was concluded too inconsiderately.
on fate ¶ -
Timaeus Cicero, Marcus Tullius 1 neutral 1 citation
Required companion quote_event for the citation of Carneades as the source of the debating method mentioned.
Much have I written, both in my Academic treatises, against the natural philosophers, and often debated, in the manner and method of Carneades, with Publius Nigidius.
timaeus ¶
the marks
- authority
- relied on as a source of legitimacy
- neutral
- identified or reported
- refuted
- argued against
- extended
- developed or continued
- endorsed
- agreed with
- roman
- the cited text is in the library and opens in the reader
- italic
- named by this text, not held by the library — the corpus's wanted list
- ¶
- the passage in this text that does the citing
- 7
- beside a chapter, the passages anchored there. A single citation can quote more than one passage, which is why a row carries two figures: the citations the harvest recorded, and the passages its chapters add up to.