Comma for either/or — dharma, courage. Spelling forgiving — corage finds courage.

    The Atlas

    The quotation ledger

    25,771 utterances carried inside 339 works, naming 13,004 quoted parties and 3,405 speakers. Where the citation ledger records a text leaning on a source, this records words being repeated: in quotation, in report, or as an authority carried forward.

    5,810 quoted · 5,090 reported · 14,871 carried

    most-quoted

    60 of 1,172
    1. 375 utterances in 2 works

      10 reported · 365 carried

      340 authority 4 neutral 31 extended

      in the voice of Euclid, narrator

    2. 175 utterances in 28 works

      88 quoted · 74 reported · 13 carried

      16 authority 129 neutral 17 refuted 6 extended 7 endorsed

      in the voice of Socrates, Critobulus, Xenophon, Ischomachus, Strepsiades

    3. 167 utterances in 49 works

      7 quoted · 9 reported · 151 carried

      91 authority 42 neutral 15 refuted 11 extended 8 endorsed

      in the voice of Socrates, Homer, Aeschines, Agathon, Alexander

    4. 165 utterances in 8 works

      148 quoted · 17 reported

      1 authority 162 neutral 2 refuted

      in the voice of Athena, Penelope, Telemakhos, Circe, Agamemnon

    5. 127 utterances in 32 works

      5 quoted · 10 reported · 112 carried

      54 authority 28 neutral 9 refuted 19 extended 17 endorsed

      in the voice of Seneca, Plato, Scipio, Socrates, narrator

    6. 125 utterances in 19 works

      1 quoted · 2 reported · 122 carried

      117 authority 2 neutral 1 refuted 5 extended

      in the voice of David, Barlaam, Basil of Caesarea, Clement of Alexandria, The author

    7. 111 utterances in 26 works

      12 quoted · 66 reported · 33 carried

      14 authority 67 neutral 20 refuted 1 extended 9 endorsed

      in the voice of Aeschines, Demosthenes, the clerk, the speaker, Aristophanes the Olynthian

    8. 110 utterances in 26 works

      4 quoted · 9 reported · 97 carried

      31 authority 32 neutral 9 refuted 8 extended 30 endorsed

      in the voice of Aristotle, Cicero, Piso, The commentator, Miskawayh

    9. 109 utterances in 18 works

      1 quoted · 1 reported · 107 carried

      96 authority 8 neutral 2 refuted 3 extended

      in the voice of Isaiah, Barlaam, Tertullian, Basil, the Creator

    10. 104 utterances in 20 works

      2 quoted · 2 reported · 100 carried

      87 authority 3 neutral 2 refuted 9 extended 3 endorsed

      in the voice of Paul, Basil of Caesarea, Paul (the Apostle), Bar Hebraeus, Barlaam

    11. 100 utterances in 7 works

      71 quoted · 29 reported

      10 authority 79 neutral 4 refuted 7 endorsed

      in the voice of the poet, poet, Indra, reciter, worshippers

    12. 91 utterances in 21 works

      17 quoted · 10 reported · 64 carried

      26 authority 23 neutral 14 refuted 7 extended 21 endorsed

      in the voice of Alexander, Socrates, the clerk, the speaker (Dio), Achilles

    13. 89 utterances in 17 works

      12 quoted · 26 reported · 51 carried

      11 authority 20 neutral 34 refuted 4 extended 20 endorsed

      in the voice of Seneca, Epicurus, Cicero, the speaker, Lucretius

    14. 82 utterances in 13 works

      5 quoted · 6 reported · 71 carried

      70 authority 11 neutral 1 refuted

      in the voice of Manu, narrator, the Self-existent One / Brahma, the poet, the poet-worshippers

    15. 80 utterances in 18 works

      5 quoted · 4 reported · 71 carried

      67 authority 8 neutral 1 refuted 4 extended

      in the voice of God, Tertullian, Bar Hebraeus, Basil of Caesarea, Jacob

    16. 77 utterances in 18 works

      6 quoted · 4 reported · 67 carried

      66 authority 8 neutral 3 extended

      in the voice of Jesus Christ, Barlaam, Basil of Caesarea, Christ, Tertullian

    17. 76 utterances in 12 works

      8 quoted · 1 reported · 67 carried

      67 authority 1 neutral 1 refuted 4 extended 3 endorsed

      in the voice of Christ / the Lord, Christ, the Lord, Jesus Christ, Barlaam

    18. 74 utterances in 16 works

      62 quoted · 12 reported

      3 authority 69 neutral 1 refuted 1 endorsed

      in the voice of Hera, Athena, Poseidon, Chorus, Iris

    19. 71 utterances in 21 works

      12 quoted · 59 reported

      7 authority 41 neutral 16 refuted 7 endorsed

      in the voice of Demosthenes, Plataeans, Thebans, Philip, Pro-Macedonian speakers in Athens

    20. 66 utterances in 19 works

      2 quoted · 64 carried

      57 authority 2 refuted 5 extended 2 endorsed

      in the voice of Paul, Tertullian, Paul the Apostle, the narrator, Barlaam

    21. 65 utterances in 16 works

      9 quoted · 2 reported · 54 carried

      55 authority 4 neutral 3 refuted 2 extended 1 endorsed

      in the voice of Basil of Caesarea, Jesus Christ, Barlaam, John, Clement

    22. 64 utterances in 9 works

      52 quoted · 12 reported

      2 authority 61 neutral 1 refuted

      in the voice of Odysseus, Agamemnon, Thetis, Hektor, Priam

    23. 63 utterances in 6 works

      51 quoted · 12 reported

      4 authority 56 neutral 1 refuted 2 endorsed

      in the voice of the poet, ritual practitioner, ritual performer, the worshippers, Agni

    24. 62 utterances in 17 works

      6 quoted · 2 reported · 54 carried

      18 authority 22 neutral 6 refuted 4 extended 12 endorsed

      in the voice of Euripides, Aeschines, Clement, Dio Chrysostom, Alexander

    25. 60 utterances in 10 works

      4 quoted · 48 reported · 8 carried

      1 authority 36 neutral 21 refuted 2 endorsed

      in the voice of Demosthenes, Aeschines, Aeschines' brothers, narrator (Seneca, imagining Aeschines's thought)

    26. 58 utterances in 4 works

      44 quoted · 14 reported

      1 authority 55 neutral 1 refuted 1 endorsed

      in the voice of Araspas, Cyaxares, Gadatas, Croesus, Astyages

    27. 56 utterances in 3 works

      50 quoted · 4 reported · 2 carried

      2 authority 54 neutral

      in the voice of Rāma, Janaka, Vasiṣṭha, Brahmā, Daśaratha

    28. 55 utterances in 8 works

      50 quoted · 5 reported

      52 neutral 1 refuted 2 endorsed

      in the voice of Achilles, Clytemnestra, Nestor, Odysseus, Chorus

    29. 53 utterances in 11 works

      1 quoted · 52 carried

      51 authority 1 neutral 1 refuted

      in the voice of Jalāl al-Dīn al-Dawwānī, al-Ghazzālī, Abū Ṭālib al-Makkī, H. N., Ibn Rushd

    30. 53 utterances in 29 works

      32 quoted · 20 reported · 1 carried

      17 authority 34 neutral 1 refuted 1 endorsed

      in the voice of God, Brahmā, Viṣṇu, the gods, Ariston

    31. 52 utterances in 12 works

      3 quoted · 2 reported · 47 carried

      31 authority 12 neutral 6 refuted 3 extended

      in the voice of William Blackstone, Blackstone, John Taylor of Caroline

    32. 52 utterances in 10 works

      1 quoted · 5 reported · 46 carried

      42 authority 9 neutral 1 refuted

      in the voice of Aulus Gellius, the speaker (Cicero)

    33. 50 utterances in 7 works

      14 quoted · 6 reported · 30 carried

      14 authority 18 neutral 8 refuted 4 extended 6 endorsed

      in the voice of Jeremy Bentham, A. V. Dicey, Henry Sumner Maine, Bentham and his disciples, Henry Brougham

    34. 50 utterances in 4 works

      9 quoted · 8 reported · 33 carried

      39 authority 7 neutral 4 extended

      in the voice of King John, the barons, Counsel for Sir Edmund Hampden, Counsel for Sir John Heveningham, Magna Carta

    35. 49 utterances in 14 works

      34 quoted · 15 reported

      4 authority 35 neutral 5 refuted 5 endorsed

      in the voice of Hermes, Chorus, Creusa, Athena, Zeus

    36. 48 utterances in 7 works

      2 quoted · 46 carried

      44 authority 2 extended 2 endorsed

      in the voice of Solomon, Wisdom, Basil, Basil of Caesarea

    37. 47 utterances in 14 works

      6 quoted · 20 reported · 21 carried

      12 authority 28 neutral 1 refuted 3 extended 3 endorsed

      in the voice of Isocrates, Lysimachus, Former pupil who praised Sparta, Isocrates' associate, Accusers of Isocrates

    38. 47 utterances in 10 works

      20 quoted · 18 reported · 9 carried

      23 authority 19 neutral 3 refuted 2 endorsed

      in the voice of Jesus Christ, the disciples, Angels, Bar Hebraeus, Basil

    39. 46 utterances in 4 works

      1 quoted · 45 carried

      35 authority 8 neutral 2 extended 1 endorsed

      in the voice of Ulpian, Aristo

    40. 46 utterances in 6 works

      5 quoted · 10 reported · 31 carried

      25 authority 16 neutral 1 refuted 3 extended 1 endorsed

      in the voice of Gaius, Justinian

    41. 43 utterances in 13 works

      43 carried

      40 authority 2 neutral 1 extended

      in the voice of Jeremiah, the Lord, Basil of Caesarea, God, the Spirit

    42. 43 utterances in 2 works

      32 quoted · 11 reported

      1 authority 41 neutral 1 refuted

      in the voice of Artabanus, Demaratus, Mardonius, Masistes, Pythius

    43. 42 utterances in 7 works

      40 quoted · 1 reported · 1 carried

      2 authority 37 neutral 1 refuted 2 endorsed

      in the voice of Odysseus, Hera, Telemakhos, Zeus, Achilles

    44. 38 utterances in 15 works

      1 quoted · 3 reported · 34 carried

      33 authority 5 neutral

      in the voice of Paul, Bar Hebraeus, narrator, Barlaam, Basil

    45. 38 utterances in 14 works

      3 quoted · 3 reported · 32 carried

      26 authority 6 neutral 1 refuted 5 extended

      in the voice of Paul, Barlaam, Paul the Apostle, Tertullian, the Converted Satrap (the Hermit)

    46. 37 utterances in 12 works

      13 quoted · 23 reported · 1 carried

      3 authority 30 neutral 3 refuted 1 endorsed

      in the voice of Diogenes, Alexander, narrator, Alexander son of Amyntas, Amyntas

    47. 37 utterances in 14 works

      2 quoted · 1 reported · 34 carried

      16 authority 11 neutral 1 refuted 5 extended 4 endorsed

      in the voice of Socrates, Alexander, Chorus, Clement, Dio Chrysostom (speaker)

    48. 36 utterances in 11 works

      3 quoted · 3 reported · 30 carried

      31 authority 3 neutral 2 extended

      in the voice of God, Moses, Bar Hebraeus, The author, Barlaam

    49. 36 utterances in 3 works

      1 quoted · 1 reported · 34 carried

      31 authority 1 neutral 4 extended

      in the voice of Justinian (Institutes)

    50. 36 utterances in 8 works

      14 quoted · 22 reported

      7 authority 21 neutral 7 refuted 1 endorsed

      in the voice of Demosthenes, Pericles, the Pythia (Delphic Oracle), Agis, Alcibiades

    51. 35 utterances in 11 works

      1 quoted · 12 reported · 22 carried

      6 authority 10 neutral 8 refuted 6 extended 5 endorsed

      in the voice of Cicero, Seneca, Chrysippus, Cotta, Marcus Aurelius

    52. 35 utterances in 17 works

      1 quoted · 3 reported · 31 carried

      19 authority 9 neutral 3 refuted 2 extended 2 endorsed

      in the voice of Socrates, Aeschines, narrator, the Heliconian Muses, Adeimantus

    53. 35 utterances in 12 works

      1 reported · 34 carried

      32 authority 3 neutral

      in the voice of Annaṃbhaṭṭa, Jaṭāyu, Supārśva (counsellor), Sītā

    54. 34 utterances in 7 works

      14 quoted · 14 reported · 6 carried

      29 authority 2 neutral 3 refuted

      in the voice of Muhammad, al-Māwardī, Abū al-Dardāʼ, Anas ibn Mālik, Aḥmad ibn Khalīl al-Khuwayyī

    55. 33 utterances in 11 works

      5 quoted · 21 reported · 7 carried

      4 authority 18 neutral 9 refuted 2 endorsed

      in the voice of defense speaker, Polycles, Nicostratus, Adversaries of Apollodorus, Timotheus

    56. 33 utterances in 9 works

      25 quoted · 6 reported · 2 carried

      12 authority 19 neutral 1 refuted 1 extended

      in the voice of Christ, Peter, Pontius Pilate, Tertullian, Tertullian, in the persona of Israel and the disciples

    57. 31 utterances in 5 works

      4 quoted · 3 reported · 24 carried

      25 authority 6 neutral

      in the voice of ritual practitioner, poet/worshipper, the poet, worshipper/poet

    58. 31 utterances in 12 works

      16 quoted · 15 reported

      1 authority 25 neutral 4 refuted 1 endorsed

      in the voice of Philip, Demosthenes, Callias, Aeschines, Aristodemus

    59. 30 utterances in 12 works

      2 quoted · 28 carried

      25 authority 4 neutral 1 refuted

      in the voice of Moses, Omer Talon

    60. 30 utterances in 9 works

      30 carried

      27 authority 1 neutral 2 extended

      in the voice of Paul, Clement, Paul the Apostle, the apostle, the narrator

    the marks
    authority
    relied on as a source of legitimacy
    neutral
    identified or reported
    refuted
    argued against
    extended
    developed or continued
    endorsed
    agreed with
    roman
    the cited text is in the library and opens in the reader
    italic
    named by this text, not held by the library — the corpus's wanted list
    the passage in this text that does the citing
    7
    beside a chapter, the passages anchored there. A single citation can quote more than one passage, which is why a row carries two figures: the citations the harvest recorded, and the passages its chapters add up to.

    marks a party quoted as a person rather than as a text — a speaker in the tradition, not an entry on the list of books to acquire.

    the speakers

    60 of 3,405

    Who does the quoting. A speaker is whoever the text puts the words in the mouth of — often a character rather than an author, which is why Rāma speaks 293 times in one work and Demosthenes 500 across thirty-four.

    1. Demosthenes 500 in 34 works
    2. Socrates 379 in 20 works
    3. Rāma 293 in 1 work
    4. Seneca 197 in 14 works
    5. Aeschines 157 in 7 works
    6. Odysseus 138 in 6 works
    7. Isocrates 110 in 19 works
    8. Jalāl al-Dīn al-Dawwānī 102 in 1 work
    9. Cicero 101 in 7 works
    10. Narrator 100 in 27 works
    11. Tertullian 96 in 17 works
    12. Speaker 95 in 8 works
    13. the poet 92 in 4 works
    14. Sītā 87 in 1 work
    15. Cyrus 82 in 6 works
    16. Hanumān 82 in 1 work
    17. Rāvaṇa 82 in 1 work
    18. The author 82 in 15 works
    19. Paul 79 in 7 works
    20. Achilles 78 in 6 works
    21. Barlaam 75 in 1 work
    22. Lakṣmaṇa 73 in 1 work
    23. Jamāl al-Dīn al-Qāsimī 72 in 1 work
    24. Chorus 67 in 20 works
    25. Jesus Christ 66 in 14 works
    26. Apollodorus 63 in 9 works
    27. Basil of Caesarea 62 in 1 work
    28. The annotator of Bayan zaghl al-ilm 62 in 1 work
    29. Agamemnon 61 in 7 works
    30. Christ 61 in 11 works
    31. The commentator 59 in 1 work
    32. Zeus 58 in 9 works
    33. Cotta 57 in 1 work
    34. A. V. Dicey 56 in 1 work
    35. Athena 55 in 9 works
    36. al-Māwardī 55 in 2 works
    37. the speaker (Cicero) 53 in 1 work
    38. Clement 51 in 2 works
    39. God 51 in 21 works
    40. Messenger 51 in 16 works
    41. clerk 51 in 10 works
    42. Viśvāmitra 50 in 1 work
    43. Sugrīva 49 in 1 work
    44. the speaker 48 in 14 works
    45. The Lord 46 in 9 works
    46. the reciter 46 in 2 works
    47. Mantitheus 44 in 2 works
    48. Basil 43 in 1 work
    49. Josaphat 43 in 1 work
    50. Telemakhos 43 in 1 work
    51. Daśaratha 41 in 1 work
    52. Alexander 40 in 5 works
    53. Apollo 40 in 12 works
    54. Philip 40 in 5 works
    55. Bar Hebraeus 38 in 1 work
    56. Salīm al-Jazāʼirī 38 in 1 work
    57. William Sharp McKechnie 38 in 1 work
    58. Bharata 37 in 1 work
    59. Hektor 36 in 1 work
    60. Jurji Zaydan 36 in 1 work

    index of quoted parties

    1,172 with pages

    Every party quoted by two or more works, or held by the library. The 11,832 quoted exactly once appear on the page of the work that quotes them, where the locus is printed.

    A

    C

    P